I kind of think it is sad to see that the people criticising the GM are two of the newest people here. I assumed that the reason he doesn't have a great deal of RP posts here at the moment is because in his story line he is kind of out of commission. It is hard to RP with people when you are locked in a boiler room at the mercy of a maniac. Justy my 2c.
Also, as to the squash matches... while they can hurt a show you have to realize that a GM trying to balance level, entrances, and wrestler score only has so much to work with. If you have a wrestler who is in a range with nobody close to him he either gets squashed, does some squashing, or doesn't get a match at all. If he doesn't get a match at all then a lot of times he ends up leaving the fed.
As far as I have seen so far, the GM is doing an excellent job writing in stories with the lack of roleplay on the forums.